
Coterie Cathedral Hill
San Francisco · assisted living
From $9,900 per month
4.9/5Google · 105 reviews
Coterie Cathedral Hill and Portola Gardens both offer assisted living in San Francisco, California. Portola Gardens starts at $3,695 per month, $6,205 (63%) less than Coterie Cathedral Hill at $9,900.
Based on 38 published reviews, the newest from August 2026. No home pays to rank higher.

San Francisco · assisted living
From $9,900 per month
4.9/5Google · 105 reviews

San Francisco · assisted living
From $3,695 per month
4.8/5Google · 5 reviews
$9,900
Coterie Cathedral Hill
$3,695
Portola GardensLower starting price
4.9/5
Coterie Cathedral HillGoogle
4.8/5
Portola Gardens
260 beds
Coterie Cathedral Hill
132 beds
Portola Gardens
5
Coterie Cathedral Hill
4
Portola GardensFewer serious citations
0.1 mi
Coterie Cathedral HillCloser to a hospital
0.9 mi
Portola Gardens
4.1 mi
Between the two homes
Coterie Cathedral Hill
Portola Gardens
From $9,900
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
From $3,695Lower starting price
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
5 serious citations in 3 years
State inspection
4 serious citations in 3 years
State inspection
260 beds
132 beds
Active
CA 385601116
Active
CA 385601045
Private pay
Medicaid (Medi-Cal), Medicaid waiver (Assisted Living Waiver), Private pay
Not published
From $3,695
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $4,595
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
From $13,495
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
From $5,795Lower price for this room
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $7,595
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
From $9,900
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $9,900
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $10,500
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $11,900
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $16,195
per month · Caring
Not published
From $17,500
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
From $18,000
per month · Caring
Not published
From $18,300
per month · Seniorly / CareScout
Not published
0.1 miCloser to a hospital
California Pacific Medical Center- Van Ness Campus
0.9 mi
Jewish Home & Rehab Center
February 2022
April 2019
ASeveral accounts
“The lunch we had was quite good and people were friendly.”
“For #6, the food looks amazing, but we haven't tried it yet.”
“Whether enjoying a delicious meal, working out at the gym, watching a movie or sharing a cup of coffee it is all part of a wonderful experience.”
“The activities, dining, and services are exactly what you would want for a loved one, and the studio designs are among the best I have seen.”
“We tried a meal at one of the dining rooms, and it felt just like we were out at a nice restaurant.”
“The dining is excellent with 2 restaurants and a bar (with live music multiple times a week).”
“The food is good.”
“I will say that she said she was very well cared for, the food was excellent and she appreciated the availability of transportation and activities.”
“Besides the filters being as bad as they are I also noticed the floors in the main dining room be severely scratched and poorly maintained.”
“Besides the filters being as bad as they are I also noticed the floors in the main dining room be severely scratched and poorly maintained.”
ASeveral accounts
“FOOD: I have visited but have not participated in any meals.”
“I saw the menu.”
“As Powers of Attorney for our sister, we are thankful for the loving, mindful, efficient and consistent care our sister receives and love the amount of time Portola Gardens puts into the wellbeing and socializing of their Residents with quality activities and homemade healthy food!”
“She the food all the time and it smells good.”
“The menu looks good and they offer different options for different dietary needs.”
ASeveral accounts
“I feel cared for by our superb staff, feel engaged in our diverse activities, entertained by so many events and pleasantly surrounded by friendly and interesting fellow residents.”
“The activities, dining, and services are exactly what you would want for a loved one, and the studio designs are among the best I have seen.”
“The dining is excellent with 2 restaurants and a bar (with live music multiple times a week).”
“There are exercise classes and the swimming pool is great.”
“I will say that she said she was very well cared for, the food was excellent and she appreciated the availability of transportation and activities.”
ASeveral accounts
“ACTIVITIES: Those that I have observed seem to fit the needs of the residents.”
“Just walking into the facility, you could tell that they had a lot of activities going on, and everybody was very engaged.”
“Our family is beyond grateful for the exquisite care our sister is receiving from the nursing staff, the activities coordinators and especially Lynda Connelly who has been a pillar of support and professionalism alongside the rest of the Executive & Business Staff.”
“They did have a big activity area; they had quite a few.”
“They did have activities going on, but not many.”
“I recommended them to a couple of my friends' moms.”
“It has a large day room for residents with lounger chairs to rest and watch television, listen to music or play games.”
“They have daily activities and the community is very clean.”
CLimited detail
ASeveral accountsMore detail
“We chose Portola Gardens to care for our mom during her time in hospice, and overall, we’re grateful we found this facility when we needed it most.”
“I toured Portola Gardens.”
“I toured Portola Gardens.”
“Portola Gardens Assisted Living in San Francisco has been the biggest gift to our sister and family.”
“The tour at Portola Gardens was good.”
“Portola Gardens was a terrible place.”
“Portola Garden was there in a pinch.”
“Portola Gardens was huge.”
“I went to Portola Gardens.”
“Portola Gardens is a gorgeous old historic building in San Francisco.”
“My family member resided at Portola Gardens for 4 years.”
“Portola Gardens is beautiful, wonderful, and the staff is excellent.”
?Ask on tour
BTwo sources of detailMore detail
“ROOMS: The rooms are quiet and clean Residents do not need to bring their own furniture.”
“The bedroom faced the backyard, which allowed privacy, a view of the trees and the ability to admire the flowers during the Spring and Summer seasons, and fresh air from the window.”
ASeveral accountsMore detail
“She plans great outings and creates such a fun, positive atmosphere for the residents.”
“We're beginning to look around for a facility for my grandma, who is suffering from dementia, and seeing all of the events, outings and everyone's kindness with the residents helps make my family feel confident that my grandparents would be very well taken care of!”
“I will say that she said she was very well cared for, the food was excellent and she appreciated the availability of transportation and activities.”
CLimited detail
CLimited detail
CLimited detail
Portola Gardens starts at $3,695 per month, $6,205 (63%) less than Coterie Cathedral Hill at $9,900. Prices are starting rates. Ask each home for a written quote after a care assessment.
Coterie Cathedral Hill is rated higher on Google: Coterie Cathedral Hill 4.9/5 (105 reviews), Portola Gardens 4.8/5 (5 reviews).
Coterie Cathedral Hill is the larger home, licensed for 260 beds against 132 at Portola Gardens.
Coterie Cathedral Hill: active, license CA 385601116. Portola Gardens: active, license CA 385601045.
Coterie Cathedral Hill: Private pay. Portola Gardens: Medicaid (Medi-Cal), Medicaid waiver (Assisted Living Waiver), Private pay.
4.1 miles in a straight line, both in San Francisco.
State licensing inspectors issued 6 citations (5 serious) to Coterie Cathedral Hill and 13 citations (4 serious) to Portola Gardens since November 2023. Type A citations are the serious kind: an immediate risk to health or safety. Each home's full record is on the state's facility search (CDSS Community Care Licensing).
The nearest hospital is California Pacific Medical Center- Van Ness Campus (0.1 mi) for Coterie Cathedral Hill and Jewish Home & Rehab Center (0.9 mi) for Portola Gardens.
Only Coterie Cathedral Hill offers independent living. Coterie Cathedral Hill: assisted living, memory care and independent living. Portola Gardens: assisted living and memory care.
Memory care · shared room: from $13,495 at Coterie Cathedral Hill, $5,795 at Portola Gardens, the lowest published monthly price for each room. Prices are starting rates. Ask each home for a written quote after a care assessment.
They share 84 listed amenities; Coterie Cathedral Hill lists 100 the other does not, such as 24-hour nursing, adventist services and anytime dining; Portola Gardens lists 11 the other does not, such as 12-16 hour nursing, awake overnight staff and challenging behaviors.
Coterie Cathedral Hill: Best of Senior Living and Most Friendly. Portola Gardens: none listed.
Coterie Cathedral Hill: grade A, several accounts (10 reviews mention it). One review says: “The lunch we had was quite good and people were friendly.” Portola Gardens: grade A, several accounts (5 reviews mention it). One review says: “FOOD: I have visited but have not participated in any meals.”
Coterie Cathedral Hill: grade A, several accounts (5 reviews mention it). One review says: “I feel cared for by our superb staff, feel engaged in our diverse activities, entertained by so many events and pleasantly surrounded by fr…” Portola Gardens: grade A, several accounts (8 reviews mention it). One review says: “ACTIVITIES: Those that I have observed seem to fit the needs of the residents.”
Coterie Cathedral Hill: grade C, limited detail (0 reviews mention it). Portola Gardens: grade A, several accounts (12 reviews mention it). One review says: “We chose Portola Gardens to care for our mom during her time in hospice, and overall, we’re grateful we found this facility when we needed…”
Coterie Cathedral Hill: ask on tour (0 reviews mention it). Portola Gardens: grade B, two sources of detail (2 reviews mention it). One review says: “ROOMS: The rooms are quiet and clean Residents do not need to bring their own furniture.”
Coterie Cathedral Hill: grade A, several accounts (3 reviews mention it). One review says: “She plans great outings and creates such a fun, positive atmosphere for the residents.” Portola Gardens: grade C, limited detail (0 reviews mention it).
A grade measures how much the available sources say about a topic. Both praise and criticism count. A home can earn an A for dining even when reviewers disagree about the food.
We check up to 20 published reviews available through each profile, remove duplicates, and match mentions to topics. An unmentioned amenity may still be available. Clinical quality and safety are outside these grades.